offered a trade ?

[moman]

which qb should i trade off for rb j addai 1yr . i have 3 qbs / 2yr m ryan atl - 2yr qb b farve minn - 1 yr qb d mcnabb phi . between the 2 - d mcnabb or b farve which is a better trade . i was thinking d mcnabb . any help or comments on this would help out. thanks

[pittstownkiller]

Thats an interesting question. First I would start with how highly you value Addai. To me he is lower middle tier at absolute best. He has had poor numbers compared to D. Brown (not fantasy number here, mind you, but it is clear that Brown is going to take the reins soon). Once IND loses a game I think that they are going to re-assess their running game, That is your call though. I think all your QBs are good, so let play with numbers here:

Ryan @ 2 - to me he is the most unreliable of the bunch but he is young. Tough to move an alright QB in his situation.

McNabb @ 1 - to me he is the best you got but the 1 year is troubling. He can put up the numbers with the best of them and I would keep him.

Favre @ 2 - it is him that I would move, good value for this year.
My thinking here is if Favre has a big year, goes far-maybe wins it all, does he comeback? Maybe yes but you never know. That is if he even lasts, yes he played every game last season but he was hurt and fell off a cliff. The man is 40 years old, it is hard to bank on him long term. I would consider him a 1 year guy, for the purposes of ranking him on my team. He is putting up some eye-popping numbers for him (I know, he was on my roster for about 10 years) and I would move him while he hot. I also would be shooting a hell of a lot higher than Addai. Sell him to the next guy as a two year man and get a much better RB.

Now I guess you could make an argument if I'm going to consider Favre and McNabb both 1 yr. players why not move McNabb. Fair point but I would say that Favre value is probably higher which means more in return. In all reality, to me I see the duo of McNabb and Ryan being fine for you and the bigger return on Favre as the way I would go. One last thing, if you're set on Addai, and you like Favre as an option for next year, I would probably drop Ryan-and I still think that even he is too good for Addai straight-up.
_________________
Am I helping you? Please look for and answer my posts. I have one this week @
http://forums.rtsports.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=19142